It is August. There are still 4 months to go to the end of the year and my annual commuter ticket has stopped working. Issued by Irish Rail, it never worked in Dublin Bus machines, despite being a bus and rail ticket. Now it will not work in the automatic ticket validators on Irish Rail.
If I am detained in a station, platformside, and cannot leave because the ticket that you issued (and which you claim is your property) has failed to work, I will take the view that I have been falsely imprisoned.
You can issue a new ticket to me at your expense and inconvenience. I would suggest an exchange of tickets at Heuston Station.